As mentioned earlier, the Butchers of the Bell Curve group decided to put on a bit of D-Day gaming and on Friday night June 7 of this year gamed the German attacks are Le Fiere against the 82nd Airborne. Hopefully everyone can read the background from the earlier posts and we can get straight onto the actual game report.
First we have the actual game area with a 6x4 table grid shown overlaid...
... and what the table looked like once we had remembered just how quickly a 6x4 table can eat up every terrain piece in the gaming room. Causeway and flooded area to the far end of the table. Pz.100 is shown in their game starting position in the foreground about to enter Le Moley (bravely defended by three stands of chickens). Out of shot to the left is Amfreville which was defended for this game by a small German force. These Germans played no real part in the game and existed just to remind the US player the village was still hostile.
Mid left down the table is a group of trees representing the orchard in which Col Timmes and his force were located and eventually were forced back into. German infantry from 91st Division (1057th Grenadier Regiment?) are on the bottom right of the photo.
Game system is Battlefront (Fire and Fury)
. Ground scale is 1inch = 40 yards, each tank model is 2-3 vehicles and a stand is approx a squad. All US units in this game were classed as VETERAN, Pz.100 as TRAINED, 91st Division units as EXPERIENCED and the rather useless chickens as GREEN.
The battle progressed. Our brave trainee tank crews muscle their way down the road towards Conquigny which is currently defended by a very small force of paras that were historically 12 officers and men and is shown in the game as 2 stands. The trailing R-35 platoon (Old Glory models from memory) are about to be harassed with mortar fire from Col Timmes, probably as a direct result of someone (who shall remain nameless) playing Panzerlied MP3s via their tablet at about the same time. German infantry seen in this photo are the infantry platoons of Pz.100 consisting of more tank crew trainees. The platoon shown in a neat row against the hedgerow bravely spent the rest of the game in that position while the second platoon still on the road managed to advance further up the road for later glory.
Meanwhile, B company 508th decide to cross over to the west side of the river. Historical this company did not seem to be aware the Germans were currently attacking and arrived in some confusion in Conquigny before being forced south of the causeway and eventually back across the flooded area. In game this was represented by rolling an attack, modified down just enough to ensure no one would actually die, and applying the Disordered and Suppressed results. These, together with a bad activation roll for this company next turn resulted in a rather unhappy bunch of paratroopers.
The causeway is actually tree lined on both sides, making the troops a lot less exposed as they appear in the photo. Casualty markers by Peter Pig.
B/508th starts to become engaged with Pz.100. The lead R-35 (Flames of War model) has already blown away the defending group of US officers using the awesome destructive power of the SA.18 37mm gun and about to start working it's way down the column of B company. This vehicle had a great game, eventually finishing with four kills and Iron Cross with Oak Leaves and Diamonds. Some nights the dice just love you...
The Peter Pig cavalry stand is representing the commander of the Pz.100 force, not because there is any evidence they owned any horses, but basically because AWB was pleased with the paint job and wanted an excuse to have it on the table.
Nearly at the end of gaming time. The Pz.III (Old Glory) has just been forced to retire down the road after an angry bunch of paras got into the wooded area next to it and threw grenades. Not seen is the increasing pile of dead in front of the lead R-35 who calmly blew away the troops attempting to close with it during the same turn. 91st Division can be seen approaching from the right. In retrospect from a scenario design point of view these troops may have started too far from the action as crossing the numerous hedgerows took most of the game.
To the left the forces of Col Timmes are attempting to work into a position where they can engage the pair of R-35s. The para in the woods just to the left of the road is dead man walking. Next turn it will be made disordered by the deadly fire of the Super R-35 (it had a REALLY good game) before being overrun by some of the trainee crew infantry. A solid barrage of long range bazooka fire would then disorder this vehicle (red marker - troops can rally from this condition under these rules) but by then we had run out of gaming time.
In all a very enjoyable time was had by the three players. It had been easily over a year since Battlefront had been played and there was some rust to shake off and remembering the effective range of some weapons took a while, probably resulting in some overly cautious moves at the start of the game. Positioning of the 91st units, as mentioned, was probably a bit too far away as they managed to do little in the game. As the expectation was that the low quality Pz.100 would be quickly broken and removed from play, AWB (as the scenario designer) took what was assumed to be the weakest unit in order to allow the other players the majority of the game play. Best laid plans of mice and bloggers...
Recreating historical events is also always a tricky balance, especially in a situation such as this where the staggered and unco-ordinated arrival of US units had a major influence on how the battle historically unfolded. Random dice were being used to attempt to have the arrival of US FOO and 57mm AT guns as well as A Company 505th. The support units were simply rolling for each stand hoping to get a suitably high result, where A Company was using a running total where the US player would add 1D10 to his tally each turn until the magic number of 20 was reached. In the game none of these events occurred although the mechanic seemed sound and brought no complaints.
Butchers of the Bell Curve are listing this game as a success and intending to game more WW2 in 15mm in the future.
Welcome to Another Wargaming Blog, where your hosts will update randomly and infequencently about whatever takes their gaming fancy.
Spelling Optional.
Spelling Optional.
Showing posts with label Peter Pig. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Peter Pig. Show all posts
Saturday, 8 June 2013
Monday, 15 April 2013
In attack of poor Crossbows – Musings on the FoG system
In the many prestigious gaming circles
AWB mixes with there is the miniature gaming group known informally
as Butchers of the Bell Curve, a friendly and casual little group
that regularly engages in playing both Fields of Glory and the sister
publication, Fields of Glory Renaissance.
Within this group the topic of units of
crossbow armed, poor quality medium foot have become somewhat of a
running theme after during an otherwise uneventful FoG game during
November last, a six figure unit of this rubbish managed to defeat in
close combat a much more highly fancied unit of Roman types.
Members of the Butchers of the Bell
Curve have fallen into two camps. First, as supported by the owner of
said crossbowmen, is that they are clearly excellence value for money
and all armies should got to the effort of fielding them. The other
faction, as shamelessly supported by AWB among others, is that they
are cheap rubbish and you get what you paid for.
Let us now take this harmless debate
and shamelessly poke it with a stick a few times to make it angry.
First up let us revise the basic
functions of shooting combat under the FoG system. First up is to try
and remove stands, a task that requires getting a minimum of three
hits per shooting phase due to the -2 DRM on the Kill Dice the game
system uses, and second is to try and force Cohesion Tests on your
target using the slightly easier task of inflicting at least 1 hit
per three bases. (Which, for example, would mean two hits if shooting
at a six base sized target).
Anything else is wasted so if you
cannot get hits on your target then you are only annoying him and
slowing the game down.
Crossbows, while no doubt an easy
weapon to train your smelly peasant to operate and quite capable of
punching through armour, were slightly slower to fire then other
missile weapons in this period and hence for most foot targets under
the game system they are at a disadvantage. In game terms this means
hitting on 5s or 6s when trying to go head to head with say an enemy
unit of foot skirmishers. As the system requires Poor rated troops to
re-roll any raw 6s and keep the new result, this means a single D6
will give a hit approximately every 22%.
Not too bad, you might say, but
remember you need at least two hits on your six base large target to
force a test and at least three to have a chance of removing a stand.
So, assuming you are rolling 4 dice (as
that is what AWB have crunched the numbers for and cannot really be
arsed doing them again), it means you will score 3 or more hits (and
maybe kill a stand) about 4% of the time and cause two or more hits
(enough for a Cohesion Test) a slightly more impressive 21% of the
time.
Which all seem wonderful so let us
compare to an Average rated unit under the same conditions.
Now no longer having to re-roll 6s, a
dice will hit 33% of the time and the chances of 3 or more hits
become 11% and two or more 41%. The loose conclusion is that Average
Crossbow are about twice as good just from shooting.
Things get worse when you allow for the
fact that your unit may also receive fire and be forced to take tests
themselves. While Cohesion Tests have many DRMs and are difficult to
fully break down into a simple figure, if you assume an unmodified
roll, a Poor unit will pass 42% of the time compared to 58% for an
Average unit.
So, going head to head between an
Average and Poor unit lined up and shooting at each other with four
dice each, the Poor unit will drop a Cohesion level about 23% of the
time compared to only 9% for the Average unit. Of course once a unit
starts dropping levels they lose dice and gain negative DRM and it
all starts to get rapidly worse.
(AWB also admits that under the system
the firing units may not actually have four dice, but cannot find
their maths text books and had to crunch the numbers the long and
painful way. Just work with us here, okay?)
That is just shooting. What happens
when you get into close combat?
While without going deep into each and
every army list, it is a safe assumption that most crossbow units are
not going to be armoured and not going to be wielding a secondary
(melee) type weapon. Hence the chances of going into a combat round
at a major disadvantage and needing to hit on 6s are quite realistic
and high, which would already be bad enough if Poor troops didn't
have that re-roll requirement. Since the odds of getting a hit with
one dice under this situation works out to approximately 3%, unless
you can fight from a good defensive position (say uphill like the
unit that managed to start this entire discussion back in late 2012),
then you are not going to cause more hits in the combat, you are not
going to force the enemy to take kill tests, you are going to be the
one who is taking the Cohesion tests yourself and unless you manage
to really butcher the bell curve, you are going to die.
Well, so what? The entire unit probably
only cost you 12 or 18 points out of your 800pt army so who is going
to get upset?
Well winning the game under FoG
involves breaking an army and a dead unit counts towards the break
point no matter how cheap and nasty it is. Also a routing unit always
runs the risk of upsetting nearby friends as well as opening a hole
to allow the opponent one more closer to looting your baggage.
Yes a cheap unit does make your army
bigger which is always a good thing, but the original argument
against fielding Poor Crossbowmen is that you get what you pay for.
Always remember they are extremely unlikely to dish out much damage
and have little staying power if even remotely seriously engaged. If
they are making up the numbers and help support your cunning tactical
victory over the enemies foolishly over extended armoured cavalry
then they have earned their worth. If you place them on your critical
flank and they die horribly then more fool you we say.
Still, your army. Your dice. Have fun.
(as a disclaimer, AWB is currently
painting some Peter Pig crossbowmen to take part in a Maximilian
Imperial army which do have the option of being taken as Poor for
2pts a stand. AWB wishes to make it clear that they in one way wish
to appear as hypocrites, just merely as extremely slow painters.)
Wednesday, 10 April 2013
Painting Projects from the Bottom of the Figure Pile (1)
In what no doubt made perfect sense at the time, AWB seems to have at one stage purchased some 15mm Nuns from Peter Pig. They are classic pengiun style, have some figures armed with nasty looking sticks and are all rather angry looking.
Why AWB decided to own these is anyone's guess. What AWB is going to do with said figures is alway open to speculation. While they may have been purchased as part of the incedibly slow moving Tomorrow's War 'Fallout' project - in which case they probably should be based up as individual figures - AWB struggles to see a need for a crack squad of Nuns fighting their way across a 15mm Capital Wasteland and hence the current plan is to base them up as a small unit of Fields of Glory horde.
Why AWB decided to own these is anyone's guess. What AWB is going to do with said figures is alway open to speculation. While they may have been purchased as part of the incedibly slow moving Tomorrow's War 'Fallout' project - in which case they probably should be based up as individual figures - AWB struggles to see a need for a crack squad of Nuns fighting their way across a 15mm Capital Wasteland and hence the current plan is to base them up as a small unit of Fields of Glory horde.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
