Welcome to Another Wargaming Blog, where your hosts will update randomly and infequencently about whatever takes their gaming fancy.

Spelling Optional.

Sunday, 5 May 2013

TV - The Boffin vs AWB - victory to the Boffin

Sunday night TV as we know it came to a crashing end just after the credits to Doctor Who this week. The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier were back and for the first time ever have managed to crush AWB's ego by not giving your blog host anything to moan about.
This week our power trio left the 20th century and jumped back to the 1860s to play with the Spencer Carbine. Armed with some stereotypes of good old boys (whatever they actually are), a few lines from both the Battle Hymn and Dixie and some butternut pumpkin jokes that were probably way too subtle for even most history buffs, our heroes give us viewers a brief overview of the US Civil War to give us an understanding of the then current weapons and tactics before introducing us to the rather advanced Spencer Rifle.
The Spencer was of course a level action rifle firing rim fire cartridges from a tubular magazine in the stock at a time when the vast majority of troops were issued with percussion fired muzzle loading rifles. In order to show the massive increase in firepower our gang organises a 60 second shoot off between two of them with rifled muskets and one with a Spencer Carbine.
All good fun, especially with the add of visually pleasing water filled barrels as targets, before closing off with the claim that it wasn't so much the firepower weapons like the Spencer gave the North that lead to their victory, but the fact that the industrialised North had the production ability to make such equipment in the first place.
Roll credits and roll the AWB jaw off the floor for suddenly realising there is nothing much to whinge about in the next blog update.
Curse you TBCubed!!
AWB, being the quality and well loved blog that it is, will stand up regardless and find something to moan about. The Spencer was never shown to be reloaded, which is someone of a pity. Being a tubular magazine, pre loaded tubes from a Blakeslee Cartridge Box could be simply tipped straight into the weapon, an ability that complimented the relatively fast lever action. A comparison of effective range may have been of interest, although since the team clearly seemed to only have access to the Carbine instead of the longer Spencer Rifle, any test may have been an apples to oranges conclusion. Some discussion into the relative costs between the two weapons and hence the ability to actually raise units equipped with these weapons may have also been useful.
And... ummm.. as you can see, AWB is struggling a little to find faults. (Curse you AGAIN TBCubed!). All up this was a tidy little episode. Unlike previous eps, they avoided actually making claims that they were going to 'prove' something and instead settled for just showing the people at home the difference between the older and newer weapons. Having finished, with nothing actually being proved, there was no danger of coming up with the sort of broad and sweeping statement that has given AWB so much writing pleasure over the last month. Of slight disappointment was the insistence of showing the Confederate soldier as some sort of inbreed hick with bad teeth and the cringe worthy accents the three tried to put on while 'in character' but by and large a very tidy 10 minutes of TV entertainment.

Friday, 3 May 2013

Don't Starve

As a complete procrastination from doing things constructive, AWB has been playing Don't Starve.
Don't Starve is an 'indy' computer game available from Steam and is pretty much a sandbox type adventure game where your prime function is, well, to make sure you Don't Starve.
It's all rather cute. The game plays as a sort of isometric view scroller and while the world is 3D, you are more a 2D cartoon who hops around with cheery looking animation. Your world is basically mildly surreal. The game itself doesn't offer a huge back story, and basically your hero wakes up with a smug guy standing over you pointing out it will be dark soon and maybe you should go find something to eat.
Okay.... That is helpful...
Well, there is a prequel on YouTube where you get to see your hero was an unsuccessful mad scientist type who in return for forbidden knowledge was basically dragged down by shadow hands into another dimension. A moral there for all of us one would think, and that would basically be, "When your radio starts offering you forbidden knowledge, it's time to get an MP3 player."
Your hero bounces around this world exploring and all the while collecting anything that isn't tied down. Having collected a bunch of items, you then get to craft bigger items which do bigger things in an escalating item race. For example 'flint' can be found on the ground. 'Twigs' can be gathered by hand from saplings and crafted into an Axe or a Pick which can be used to either chop down trees (giving you 'wood' and 'pine cones') or mine rocks (giving you 'stone', more 'flint', and sometimes 'gold'). Wood is useful as then you can light a fire. Did you forget the warning about it being dark soon? Ummm... oppps.
The day cycle starts at day and eventually drifts into twilight. Twilight isn't really that bad although some of the more anti social creatures become more active then. However once night falls it becomes dark... and scary things live in the dark.
Scary? Yes, scary. The game has three values your hero needs to keep track of. Hunger is basic enough as is Health, but in the middle is your Sanity. Stray too far from the warm happy firelight and the scary things in the dark slowly sap your mind. Get in complete darkness and some honking great monster just smites you. Game over.
Losing your Sanity has an active effect. As it drops strange shadow creatures start to appear and your vision blurs a bit. Drop some more and the normally cute rabbits that hang around turn into scary black 'Beardlings'. Go completely loopy and the shadows become solid and actually attack you.
Which would be bad as if you die, you are fully dead. There are some touch stone areas you can activate which will respawn you if you die (at half sanity cause seriously, who wants to wake up inside some stone thing?), but otherwise the game runs in a sort of 'Ironman' mode where you can only save if you are still alive. Die and it cashes out your XP (to unlock new characters) and wipes all your saves.
The exception is if you manage to find 'Maxwell's Door' within your game. Entering the door takes you into Adventure Mode where you are questing against the smug git who trapped you here in the first place. If you die in Adventure Mode you find yourself respawned outside the door. Since you need to actually find Maxwell's Door before you can even start Adventure Mode, that is probably a good thing.
It's a tricky little game. After about 20 days surviving, the world turns to winter and you get to add the task of keeping warm to all your other problems. Food goes off with time, so it is the balance of eating while it is fresh or trying to manage it for the winter. Meat can be dried if you manage to build a drying rack and rabbits, if caught in the traps you can make, can be stored in boxes till the time you need to murder them.
Yes, the game term actually is 'murder', not so much because you don't then get to eat them, but just to mess with your sanity point rating some more. Cutting down trees can also be risky as if another tree sees you do it, there is a change a Tree Guardian will appear and follow you around like an unwashed 12 foot high hippy in a pine needle suit to try and kill you. To make things funnier, unlike other monsters, a Tree Guardian never forgets and doesn't loose interest if you manage to flee far enough. Just the thing when night is about to fall and you are trying to desperately gather enough wood to keep that life protecting circle of light going.
(and yes, in the middle of that he will walk though your camp fire, catch alight and then while blazing away manage to burn down half your camp as he continues to chase you. What joy!)
AWB have managed to survive 23 days so far (before freezing in winter) and unlocked the first four characters. Adventure mode still lays hidden somewhere and the joys of cooking Monster Lasagna are still unknown.
Good sanity draining fun, especially at meals times :)

Wednesday, 1 May 2013

Musing on Artillery

AWB has been doing some casual research into the multi model joy that is WW1 era artillery, and, as a result, has been musing on just what a significant development the French 75 actually was. The Matériel de 75mm Mle 1897, to give the weapon it's official name, can probably safely be called the first of the 'Modern Artillery' systems to go into service anywhere in the world, yet it's significance is probably mostly ignored by most casual students of history.
The evolution of tube artillery broadly went something like this;
- Muzzle loading smoothbore
- Muzzle loading rifled
- Breech loading
- 'Modern' weapons with recoil systems.
The progression wasn't smooth of course. Breech loading cannons of various forms date back to the beginning of gunpowder. Smoothbore cannons had some advantages over rifled cannons so both existed on the 19th Century battlefield for many years and even when breech loading had finally come up for consideration again, it was years before it managed to replace muzzle loading with some nations. The Royal Navy, having embraced the Armstrong breech loader in about 1860, decided the technology could go with a bit longer in the oven and went back to muzzle loading rifles. They stuck with such weapons probably a little longer then they needed to, eventually peaking with the RML 16 inch 80 ton weapons fitted to HMS Inflexible.
(Armstrong made an even bigger 17.7inch 100 ton weapon but even the RN decided enough was enough at that stage. The weapons were sold to Italy for some of her battleships or used on coast defence batteries in Malta and Gibraltar.)
The 75 however was a massive leap in weaponry. The key feature was of course the recoil system, a hydro-pneumatic system so advanced that it had taken designers nearly 15 years to get the idea to work successfully. This smooth and reliable system allowed the other advanced features of the gun; the automatic fuse setter and a rapid to operate breech system, to be used to their full effect. The gun could literally be fired at a rate of 30 shots per minute, a speed that was the physical upper limit based on the 2 second cycle time of the recoil system.
What is more, since unlike other guns of that period, the gun would not need to be significantly re-aimed after each shot and each of those 30 shots could be expected to go pretty much where they were intended.
Was this significant?
You better believe it.
Terence Zuber in his (cough) 'interesting' book* 'The Real Schlieffen Plan' goes as far as to claim that the German discovery of this weapon when they saw it in action during the Boxer Rebellion was enough to make them tear up their current strategic war plans and start again. Other nations, well aware of the massive rate of fire advantage this weapon had, rapidly developed or purchased their own equivalent weapons and, perhaps most significantly, the French effectively redesigned their entire battlefield tactics around it.
As we mentioned, the 75 had a very high rate of fire and a battery firing shrapnel shells was well equipped to place large areas of open ground under deadly barrages. A 1914 French Infantry division had no other artillery then this weapon and indeed a French Corps, unlike other nations which might be expected to have heavy field or howitzers, had more batteries of this gun.
However, while it was definitely a major milestone in artillery, it has also been argued that the French love affair with this weapon may have been a little unwise. Paul Strong and Sanders Marble in 'Artillery in the Great War' make the observation that in the opening battles of WW1 the superior French field artillery made a mess of the German infantry, right up to the time when the superior German HEAVY artillery suppressed and silenced the batteries.The go on to claim that a prime reason of the Allied success in the Battle of Marne was that the over extended Germans had finally advanced faster then their heavy artillery could follow and the French 75s were finally allowed to do what they were intended unopposed.
However, digressing as per usual, the point AWB really wants to muse over is how do we show these sort of technical advances on the wargames table. By the time we get to WW1 most armies, at least for their first line divisions, had quick firing field weapons. However, due to the rapid need to expand and find heavy artillery, a lot of obsolete guns were brought back into service or dragged out of distant fortresses for use on the front. The Germans were possibly an exception to this rule, but the British for example sent many 5inch Howitzers to France and used them all through 1915. These older weapons lacked recoil systems and had a practical max rate of fire of 2 shots per minute - slightly slower then the 15 or so shots most more modern guns can get off.
This brings us back to our gaming. How do our favourite rules show it, or more importantly, do we need to show it at all?
If we are modelling the slow grind of a bombardment, then probably not. While modern guns could fire faster, most work was conducted at a more sedate 1 or 2 shots per minute. There is also the very real consideration of the 'Shell Shortage' and the fact that many batteries simply didn't have enough shells to do rapid firing even if they needed to.
The really simple solution is to just ignore it totally and abstract indirect fire into an abstract where who or what fires it is not of importance. The slightly more detailed is to rationalise that shells fired x shell size = damage factor and roll against that. A simple enough concept but ignores the fact that the difference between a relatively small 'field' gun shell of say 5-6kg and the 23kg of the 5inch BL we mentioned earlier.
A field gun in many cases often completely lacked the ability to destroy entrenchments, where a heavy shell was going to collapse trenchwalls and smash firing positions. This was significant and part of the reason armies were willing to field and maintain so many different artillery types. Some guns were just better at some roles.
Each wargame system and indeed each wargamer has their own views on what makes a fun night pushing lead or counters, and each has their own view on what is worth including in a rule system. The point that AWB is trying to make is that a bigger gun/howitzer isn't just a stand with more firepower, it is a stand with DIFFERENT firepower. Field artillery can, will and did butcher troops in the open. It also can't, wont and didn't damage troops dug in. So, while your personally gaming experience is always your own, AWB would like to see games that note the difference between field and heavy shelling.
Of course AWB would also like to see game with a few less rubbish dice rolls so maybe we can't have everything...

* Interesting? Is AWB implying that they didn't really like 'The Real Schlieffen Plan'? Short answer? Yes. Zuber is an American who was posted for many years in Germany as part of his US Army service and does appear to have gone, as we say, 'native'**. While AWB has no doubt that Zuber has done a lot of research, reading his text did give the impression his book was one edit away from using the phrase 'gentle peaceloving Germans'. Zuber seems to have gone to great length to point out that Germany was forced into a defencive war against the overly aggressive Allied powers that tends to distract from his overall argument. The argument itself, namely that there was NOT actually a Schlieffen plan ends up becoming a bit moot. We all know and accept that Germany marched through Belgium so arguing if the plan existed or not unfortunately ends up a bit like claiming in your murder trial that you didn't stab the victim to death, you slashed his throat instead.

** Not that there is anything wrong with going native. AWB are big fans of Germany *** and German culture and happily pay credit to the success over the centuries of these people in both peace and war.

*** Except Hamburg