Welcome to Another Wargaming Blog, where your hosts will update randomly and infequencently about whatever takes their gaming fancy.

Spelling Optional.
Showing posts with label Television. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Television. Show all posts

Saturday, 25 May 2013

TV - Defiance = Fallout Lite?

AWB has been watching a bit of Defiance lately.
For those not in the know, Defiance is a SciFi tv show as shown on the cable channel Syfy and developed by Rockne S. O'Bannon, a man who lists the wonderful FarScape on his CV.
The premise is simple.
Alien arc fleet arrives and is embarrassed to discover Earth actually has a population.
Oops.
Tensions rise.
War breaks out.
Terraforming engines run out of control.
Peace stumbles along.
Cats and Dogs living together.
As you do.
The other gimmick is that the TV show is apparently linked in with the MMORPG of the same name where apparently actions in the game can effect story lines in the TV show. Ooooo!
AWB must confess to a LARGE amount of cynicism about this claim and seriously doubts a multi million dollar TV show will ever let itself be dictated in any way shape or form by a bunch of suicide gankers running around teabagging Noobs.
(Although, as a post modern piece of metafiction, a TV show deliberately set inside a MMORPG world may be amusing, especially if they make a few of the characters Korean based Gold Miners who are just in it for real world cash...)
So, AWB has watched a few episodes and to be honest, isn't really all that impressed. The feel here is that the show wants to be Fallout. Both have societies rebuilding between bouts of tribal factional fighting with mixtures of homemade, pre war and bleeding edge advantaged tech. The Bioman the show's lead hero fights in the pilot was so similar visually to a Super Mutant Nightkin, right down to the self mutilation scarring/serial number across it's chest that AWB was actually majorly disappointed when it didn't start arguing with itself and fire up a Stealth Boy.
Unfortunately that is about as far as it goes and there are not blue/yellow numbered jumpsuits or two headed battle cattle. There are also no aliens.
Okay there 'technically' are aliens, but they are either dialog less background dressing or latex headed humans with different hair. The major one are effectively what you would get if you ever decided to dip a goth in a hell of a lot of really strong bleach, and the others are rangas with latex nose bridges and funky contact lenses. There is also a semi cyborg race doctor character who you half expect to suddenly come out and rant "Dammit Jim, I'm an Alien, not a Caricature!" which frankly would make the character a lot more original and interesting.
Visuals aside, they are all humans, even down to the sweet little romantic sub plot between the son of the lead NegaGoth and daughter of the human mine boss.
Let's step back for a moment and muse on just how 'strange' that is. If, in the non sci fi 'real world', one was to hook up say with a sheep... well... we think we all know where that joke is going. However, at least it could be said that both humans and sheep are at least both mammals from the SAME planet. Love may conquer all, but most Xenobiologists agree that it does very little to ensure you and your new life partner from another planet have interconnecting dangly bits or even that you blood isn't mutually toxic.
On the plus side to this issue, at least the show is Syfy and not HBO or not only would we be seeing a lot of alien love, but a screenful of Alien Space Boobies each week as well.
In summary this show has clearly aimed high, and credit for trying that as the investment to set up a complete alien based SciFi show cannot be cheap. It is also a show that wants to be taken seriously. This is perhaps the biggest disappointment as to AWB at least the show has failed to make orbit. It is filled with humans with funny hair and voices instead of real aliens and mildly predicable plots (so far at least) that could be lifted and transferred in and out of just about any other TV show. Strangely, or maybe most disappointingly, O'Bannon's previous show, FarScape, a show that almost listed batshitcrazy as it's mission statement (as well as a ship, a living ship...) managed to provide us with aliens that we believed were aliens. FarScape gave us a plant as a main character FFS!
Defiance, however, just really comes across as a bit bland.

Sunday, 19 May 2013

TV - The Boffin, The Builder and The 3pdr Muzzle Loading Smoothbore

With Dr Who FINALLY redeeming itself for the year after a string of frankly pretty bland offerings, AWB sits down again on a Sunday night to watch more liberties being taken with history in the name of light entertainment.
This ep of The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier, which is apparently ep6 for those trying to follow the semi random screening order they seem to be shown in, has proved a slightly tricky one for AWB to review. On the plus side, the show finally shows some wargame figures, thereby completely vindicating AWB's decision to follow this little show for the last 8 weeks. A table full of 25s are used about mid point through the screening to give the new viewers a bit of an idea of what was actually happening in the battle they were describing, although points must be deducted as AWB is a firm believer that wargaming figures look silly with a gloss varnish.
More points are lost because the ep basically revolves around an obscure little period of European history at the start of the 19th Century that frankly is poorly documented, not very popular and of little interest to anyone. Napoleon? Never heard of him.
Okay, AWB concedes that some people MAY have heard of Napoleon, but would rather study tanks. That is the AWB mission statement and AWB will be sticking to it.
So, frantically googling to brush up on the background details, we push on with the review.
Basically our gang have got themselves a 3pdr of some sort to play with and are going to use the 1807 Battle of Friedland as an excuse to shoot it. Friedland, to paraphrase, was a battle between Russia and France that the French won and forced the Treaties of Tilsit and ended the War of the Fourth Coalition. The premise for the show was that Senarmont, then a corps artillery commander, established the principles of modern artillery by concentrating fire on a single target.
Now, as confessed before, AWB is not a shining depository of Napoleonic knowledge but some of the assumptions made here do seem very generalised and mildly misleading. A better informed description of what Senarmont did during this battle can probably be found HERE and since anything AWB is about to say was discovered from that website anyway, let us just give credit where due and direct people to the link.
What does seem to have been skipped over is the stage of the battle at which Senarmont did his party trick. The battle involved the Russians crossing over the river in order to try and smash an isolated French force and ending up being dragged into a major battle as the rest of the French army arrived. Towards evening the Russians were forced back into a constricted space with their backs to the river and it was then when Senarmont advanced his batteries and fired into the massed targets. Of minor detail not mentioned on TBCubed was the fact that Senarmont didn't do this alone, but had a battalion of infantry and four regiments of dragoons to cover him and from the accounts read by AWB, the Russians were unable or unwilling to actively counter the move forward. This sort of implies to AWB that the true conclusion to be made is not that massed firepower is a great idea (which AWB doesn't necessarily disagree with) but that aggressive use of artillery was possible or perhaps more importantly, aggressive use of a combined arms battle group was a very good and effective idea.
TBCubed rounded off the ep by showing in simple terms what happens if you break and attempt to run in the face of cavalry by having Will (the buttmonkey character) be chased across the paddock by a suitably dressed horsewoman with a big sword. (Spoiler - if you run, you die...). What did grate a bit for AWB was the casual way mounted troops were described as 'opportunists' of the battlefield and thereby reducing the reputation of an entire arm into some sort of casuals who rather then being able to dictate decisions on the battlefield, merely reacted to them.
Also rising a brief eyebrow was the attempt to explain the concept of Fog of War, a situation not actually done badly at all by our Boffin presenter, but by the war the phrase actually seems to have come full circle. Credited by most (or at least by AWB) to be a term invented by von Clausewitz to describe the literal fog produced on the battlefield by massed blackpowder weapons that reduced visibility and increased confusion, the term is so well understood by the current generation of computer/console gamers to mean limited intelligence that our Boffin had to explain that the fog of war was in this period literal in a strange case of the origin of the word coming full circle. Well, AWB was amused by it at least...
So, how much do we enjoy this episode?
Big points for showing how a muzzle loaded smooth bore cannon was operated and what a canister blast was like, points for showing the dangers of trying to run in the face of mounted troops and double plus points for the wargaming figures, but again, minus points for the massive generalisations that keep getting made that seem, to AWB at least, like they could have easily been tightened up without losing the attention of the intended audience.
Oh and massive points loss for the ABC for still not having a remotely useful supporting website.

Monday, 13 May 2013

TV - Boffins under Siege - The Trebuchet

Another Sunday and another night of light entertainment on TV as AWB current favourite free to air programming came and went. All good fun, unlike that rubbish Neil Gaiman wrote via twitter just before.
Curiously the ABC lists this ep as number 7 and last weeks (the Spencer Rifle) is listed as 8. No real idea what happened to number 6. Minor problems I am sure but if you are trying to follow at home good luck to you.
This week (or last weeks depending on numbering system) our three heroes from The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier go all medieval on us and discuss the premier pre gunpowder siege weapon, the Trebuchet. The good news here is that like last week (or next week if you prefer) the trio don't try too hard by making bold statements they can't actually prove. The framework of the programme was that the Trebuchet evolved during the so called 'Dark Ages' and the so called much more clever Romans never used them. So, ignoring the slip that the 'Dark Ages' were actually before the 'Medieval' period where the Trebuchet was actually used, the question was raised as to was this actually an effective and well designed weapon or just a hack job a mere shadow of what the Romans could have built.
Having clearly blown their budget on all those 303 rifles, the team fail to build us a full scale behemoth and instead drag out what seems to be a commercial of the shelf working model about one metre high. Jokes aside that is fair enough, they clearly do have a budget to work within but one does have to wonder why they have 'The Builder' on the programme when he often doesn't actually seem to build anything. More on the 'characters' later.
They then fling some oranges and a toy cow at a small cardboard castle before blowing it up. As you do.
Conclusions, it was a very effective weapon that could do exactly what was said on the box.
Problems really are with the casual history. No weapon exists in a vacuum, and one of the reasons why there was an evolutionary break in the development of siege weapons from Roman to Medieval times was that for a great hunk of history people stopped building decent fortifications. It is often forgotten that it was the Normans that brought castles to the British Isles and those were the much smaller Motte and Bailey style and even then, most of the first ones were made of wood. Catapults in the Roman sense were largely forgotten because most defencive works could be more easily taken using a bunch of big hairy men with some homemade ladders. The other point of interest with the historical period was that there was no real 'Engineering Class' of skilled siege specialists passing down their skills from master to apprentice. Siege, while common, was more often a case of camping outside and hoping they surrendered before your own troops got bored and attempting to knock down the walls was actually relatively uncommon. The skills to make siege equipment it seems were no so much magically unlocked like a computer game tech tree, as rediscovered and forgotten time and time again over hundreds of years and it is most likely that the people knocking down the walls with siege engines were the same skilled master craftsman who had used their knowledge of levers, pulleys and woodwork to build the great walls in the first place.
Still, a lot of history to compress into 10 minutes so let us start to muse on the shows format instead.
This ep re-introduced the character of 'Big Mama', a woman 'in her prime' who has been used before to explain to these three overgrown boys the hard physics of their problems. One guesses that this character was introduced to play up on the 'men and sheds' social stereotype where no matter how many tools a man has, he is still just a big boy trying to impress his mates and only a woman really knows how to talk sense.
Which might actually be fine if this character actually got to talk some sense.
We are given a brief 'physics' lesson on how the Big T actually works by said Big Mama, and unfortunately most of what she says is crock. A Trebuchet is effectively a long arm rotating around a pivot. Now rotational velocity is the same at both ends and, if AWB remembers correctly from Uni days, is measured in radians per second. However, the further you move away from the centre of rotation, the faster the tangential velocity and in practical terms for us in this situation, the faster our big rock is flung. Of course the Trebuchet is also a balance lever. To get one end to go down, allowing for the mechanical advantage of the lever arm, it must be heavier then the other. So Trebuchet design is in reality a compromise between size of the counter balance, length of the arms, how far they are actually hoping to throw and how big they are prepared to build the thing in the first place. Having some mother figure sprout out some dross about ratios doesn't make it otherwise and is a small step away from technobabble.
This brings us back to actual dynamic of our trio within the show. Unlike say 'Mythbusters' where the hosts are effectively being themselves and just goofing it up, TBCubed are playing classic cliched roles. Why they have chosen to do this is open to ponder. A careful pausing of the credits has finally confirmed to AWB that the head writer is also the man playing 'The Boffin' and hence is must be assumed that he (John Concannon) does actually know a respectable amount of his history. However, instead of playing himself in a sort of Adam and Jamie Mythbusters dynamic, he instead takes the role of the bully. Tony, 'The Bombardier' is the thug enforcer character and Will 'The Builder' (who as we have pointed out earlier, often doesn't build anything) gets the role of the butt monkey the crueler pair keep around as their play thing. If 'Big Mama' is seen as the school teacher bringing the schoolboys back in line then the entire show develops a disturbing parallel to the worse of most people's schooling years.
Hmmm... Still an entertaining 10 minutes of TV that AWB has been enjoying the viewing of, and all attempts at making TV of military history must really be supported, but it does have the fault of being just a tad silly.

Sunday, 5 May 2013

TV - The Boffin vs AWB - victory to the Boffin

Sunday night TV as we know it came to a crashing end just after the credits to Doctor Who this week. The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier were back and for the first time ever have managed to crush AWB's ego by not giving your blog host anything to moan about.
This week our power trio left the 20th century and jumped back to the 1860s to play with the Spencer Carbine. Armed with some stereotypes of good old boys (whatever they actually are), a few lines from both the Battle Hymn and Dixie and some butternut pumpkin jokes that were probably way too subtle for even most history buffs, our heroes give us viewers a brief overview of the US Civil War to give us an understanding of the then current weapons and tactics before introducing us to the rather advanced Spencer Rifle.
The Spencer was of course a level action rifle firing rim fire cartridges from a tubular magazine in the stock at a time when the vast majority of troops were issued with percussion fired muzzle loading rifles. In order to show the massive increase in firepower our gang organises a 60 second shoot off between two of them with rifled muskets and one with a Spencer Carbine.
All good fun, especially with the add of visually pleasing water filled barrels as targets, before closing off with the claim that it wasn't so much the firepower weapons like the Spencer gave the North that lead to their victory, but the fact that the industrialised North had the production ability to make such equipment in the first place.
Roll credits and roll the AWB jaw off the floor for suddenly realising there is nothing much to whinge about in the next blog update.
Curse you TBCubed!!
AWB, being the quality and well loved blog that it is, will stand up regardless and find something to moan about. The Spencer was never shown to be reloaded, which is someone of a pity. Being a tubular magazine, pre loaded tubes from a Blakeslee Cartridge Box could be simply tipped straight into the weapon, an ability that complimented the relatively fast lever action. A comparison of effective range may have been of interest, although since the team clearly seemed to only have access to the Carbine instead of the longer Spencer Rifle, any test may have been an apples to oranges conclusion. Some discussion into the relative costs between the two weapons and hence the ability to actually raise units equipped with these weapons may have also been useful.
And... ummm.. as you can see, AWB is struggling a little to find faults. (Curse you AGAIN TBCubed!). All up this was a tidy little episode. Unlike previous eps, they avoided actually making claims that they were going to 'prove' something and instead settled for just showing the people at home the difference between the older and newer weapons. Having finished, with nothing actually being proved, there was no danger of coming up with the sort of broad and sweeping statement that has given AWB so much writing pleasure over the last month. Of slight disappointment was the insistence of showing the Confederate soldier as some sort of inbreed hick with bad teeth and the cringe worthy accents the three tried to put on while 'in character' but by and large a very tidy 10 minutes of TV entertainment.

Monday, 29 April 2013

TV - The Boffin et al - 3

After a brief rumour that the much loved and teased ABC TV show 'The Boffin The Builder, The Bombardier only had four episodes (and hence was now over for the year), the programme happily continued to both amuse and provide cringe for the viewers here at AWB.
Ep 5 of this series, rapidly becoming much watch TV if only for the purpose of giving fuel for blog updates, remains in WW1 land but moves for the first time away from the 303 rifle. Instead we are given a brief history of the Leach Trench Catapult (also known as the Leach-Gamage Catapult) before being entertained with our three heroes flinging cricket balls across their firing range.
The Leach-Gamage, named after Mister Claude Pemberton Leach, who designed it, and Gamages, the company who made them, was a 1915 solution for the probably of bombing enemy trenches and had a brief in service period before being replaced with the types of trench mortars we are now familiar with. It was a largish Y shaped frame using rubber to fling grenades in the general direction of German and, depending on bomb and age of the rubber, was reported to have a range between 120 to 200 yards.
So, let's first talk about the show. Now it probably should be pointed out that AWB does actually enjoy watching this 10 minutes or so of three guys being man childs (and the phrase that AWB is refusing to use here is 'completely jealous'), however has an issue with the very casual conclusions that are then drawn at the end.
Our boys this week rather neatly summed up the difference between high and low angle fire to give the background of why this weapon was developed, so points to that. It may have been nice to actually mention at what range their target trench was placed as that would have given us kids at home an idea if the 120 to 200 yards claims were actually correct. Now AWB has always been a bit rubbish at judging distances and is also aware how different camera lenses can drastically foreshorten the distance, but at this stage is not fully convinced our heroes were firing at any great range.
This is a pity as to support the claim made on the show that 'it's a weapon' it would have been nice to know at what range they were capable of reaching, and perhaps more importantly, what sort of spread were they actually getting. The did (claim) to hit the target and filmed a nice little explosion to prove it (so nice it was then shown about 6 times... 'completely jealous'... cough...), but without knowing how many shots were fired (we only see about 4 cricket balls plus the final winning golf ball) we have no way of making any real conclusions.
The show also raises the chuckle, again, in their closing statements by making a comment that pretty much destroys their entire argument. It is mentioned as a bit of historical trivia that one unit in France used their catapults to send offensive messages to the Germans in clay pots. Not bombs. That does seem to AWB at least to sum up exactly how useful the troops in the trenches considered the weapon.
So what have we learnt that we can take into our wargaming?
Not a huge amount. The catapult is clearly a semi static weapon. While our TV heroes make the point it could be carried by one person, they forget that so can a 5m ladder, and just because you can carry one, doesn't mean you want to. The weapon doesn't appear to break down and moving it through a trench to a suitable firing position doesn't strike AWB as a fun task. Taking it with you during an assault also would seem to be rather pointless and of little real use.
The range of between 120 and 200 yards also gives a bit of a clue as to how it could or couldn't be useful. No Man's Land varied in depth and while there were many situations where trenches were that close apart, there were also many where they weren't. It must also be remembered that trench systems evolved to having a rather large amount of depth with forward saps and observation posts creeping out from the 'front'. It does seem that the weapon would be most used from forward saps to bomb the only targets also in range, which in many cases would be enemy forward saps. Does seem a lot of effort for little return.
In an advance, any firepower added by a catapult would have been drowned by other weapons and in defence the slow rate of fire and poor range suggests that picking up one's personal rifle may be a better idea for the crew.
Issue, as claimed in Wikipedia so it must be true, was 12 weapons per division. How this broke down or at what level they controlled at is anyone's guess.
AWB things that if squad or skirmish level WW1 is your thing, then painting and basing one of these up would be a great little extra for your games set in 1915 to early 1916 and also understands the weapon is available in 28mm. Once you start to go up in game scale the weapon would rapidly become a completely minor effect to the extent they could be completely ignored except as many figure variation in your basing.
In summary, TBCubed is still harmless largely non historical fun and it is good to see the props budget has moved on from SMLE rifles.
AWB looks forward to ep 6.

Thursday, 25 April 2013

TV - The Boffin The Builder The Bombardier - Post 2 plus Musing on Rifle Tactics

Another Sunday has been and gone on ABC free to air TV and another 15 minutes of historically slanted light entertainment has been viewed by the post Doctor Who masses.
The Boffin The Builder The Bombardier, or TBCubed for want of letter count, added to their World War One collection by 'investigating' The Mad Minute. That makes three out of four viewed programmes dedicated to WW1 and more interestingly, three out of four dedicated directly to some aspect of the .303 SMLE rifle. It this telling us something about the main period of interest for the head writer (who from speed reading the credits, AWB believes to be the 'Boffin' character. Seriously, the ABCs own website has been completely non helpful which does make one wonder where that extra $10million in funding is being wasted), or are we in reality seeing a reflection on the programmes props budget.
"Hey Davo, I've got these couple of 303s and some shoot range access. Wanna make a telly doco??"
Quite.
Anyway, back the programme. The myth of the week was the high rate of fire obtained by the highly trained career soldiers that made up the BEF during the first months of WW1 in France and how they cut down in waves the attacking Germans. The counter argument was that the musketry skills had little to do with it and the unimaginative German tactics had a lot to do with their own failure.
So, our TV heroes, to prove the claim of 15 or more aimed shots per minute set up a wall down range to represent a block of unimaginative Germans, and, stopwatch running, let fly for 60 seconds.
One minute later they had a large target filled with bullet holes and the conclusions were quickly made that the high level of training probably did have a lot to do with it, but only because of the poor German tactics.
Okay... what have we just actually proved? That three semi trained men can operate SMLE at a respectable speed? If you are ever a large plywood wall, then don't even think about going to war?
The problem here was that it is automatically assumed that the poor German tactics is an unquestionable fixed condition. True, actually proving the German tactics were poor is mildly tricky. To AWB's knowledge there are next to no photos of the Mons battles and even then, without context, they probably wouldn't be conclusive. To calculate it would probably require obtaining the (unreliable and incomplete) casualty returns, determine the axis of advance of the units involved, factor in the BEF casualties from German artillery, model using carefully calculated hit percentiles and... well.. take a wild arse guess. Point being is that you still have a whopping great variable and to draw a solid conclusion after shooting up a plywood wall is not history, it is shooting up a plywood wall.
Having solved the problems of the world in the first 5 minutes of their show, they then needed to fill in the rest of the ep and then attempted to match the record which was claimed at 32 some shots a minute. Now here our team not only didn't come close, but also didn't seem to investigate the historical situation. As AWB had it explained to them by an Australian Light Horse reinactor (so your mileage may vary, but remember we are comparing this to three guys who shoot walls), the pre-war 303 round was the round nosed MkVI. About 1916 this started to be replaced by the more powerful and pointed nose MkVII round. Now while AWB may have screwed up the mark numbers, the important thing was that the newer round had different powder and hence a far greater kick. The practical result of this was that the firer now had to hold the weapon a lot more firmly and could not get away with the previous trick of opening and closing the bolt with one's palm so that their finger tip could touch the trigger the moment the action was closed.
(try this at home with your Air 303. Imagine the bolt handle is in the centre of the palm and as you rock your hand forward your fingers are already reaching down towards the trigger in one smooth action. Bang. Repeat. Feel free to make the noises if it assists with the process.)
So, two conclusions. Either AWB was misinformed with an old wives shooting tale or TBCubed are really just three blocks shooting up plywood walls.
So, the conclusion that TBCubed is harmless non historical fun still stands.
Having successfully alienated the TBCubed crew with character assassinations, where does this leave us wargamers and what, if anything, can we learn from this?
AWB believes the prime thing to take away is that not many of us actually have a realistic grounding of what infantry firepower during the period could actually do. Your homework for this post (after you have finished playing with your air 303, air cleaned it and safely air locked it into the air weapons locker to prevent air accidents), is to dig out your current WW1 or 2 rules and find out how a machine gun is defined compared with a rifle. Most rules seem to give the tripod MG more/better firepower factors and range and leave it at that. After all, the ROF is higher, therefore more firepower. Right?
Well... maybe... and that brings us back to the idea that we do not really fully understand just how the weapons worked.
A typical Maxim style MG of the WW1 period comes in with a ROF of 600rpm cyclic. Now if you joined all the belts together and watched the cooling water you could probably keep that up for a long time. In reality most sources seem to list the practical and/or service rate of fire as more like 100-200 rpm. So if we take the middle of 150rpm and compare it to say 10 riflemen firing off 15 aimed shots per minute... Maybe apples to oranges but remember that a machine gun is a crew served weapon and depending on the army and the situation could easily have 10 men keeping it in operation so the comparison is not completely unfair.
We also need to look beyond the pure numbers of total bullets fired. Let us pretend that our team of 10 and our MG both encounter 20 enemy in the open. In this situation the 10 riflemen may prove to be more effective. They have the ability to volley fire and assuming a reasonable level of skill may only need to personally target 2 or 3 men each - easily a couple of seconds work even with bolt action rifles. Our MG in comparison, despite firing 10 rounds per second, would still to pan across the target area and, depending on the situation, may not successfully hit all the enemy before they disperse or take cover. In practical terms, the MG may actually be less 'deadly'.
However, having forced the enemy to cover, it is also probably a safe assumption that the MG would be a lot better at forcing them to stay there. If you can then act on the fact these enemy are pinned, either by moving infantry to flank or blowing them up with artillery, or both, then that is still a result and your work here is done, medals all round.
The commonly held assumption with WW1 is that the MG was the big killer, with scores of men being mown down by them. AWB feels this is at best a gross simplification and at worse just plain wrong. Accurate rifle fire could be very deadly and in fact many WW1 senior officers and trainers stressed the need for high levels of musketry training for effective assault troops, yet rifle units within WW1 gaming systems are often largely ignored. The machine gun by comparison is often a very deadly tabletop stand, where in real life it was probably not so much the killing weapon, as the denying weapon. MG fire could and did deny units the freedom to move. A more honest look at the cause of causalities in the battle will probably show that MGs killed relatively little, but instead pinned units in positions where they were unable to avoid the artillery fire that caused all the damage.
Which means what our TV heroes in TBCubed really need to do is throw away the SMLE rifles and drag out a Vickers and an 18 pounder.

Sunday, 21 April 2013

TV - The Boffin The Builder The Bombardier

Here in cheery Australia, ABC television have been recently showing a quick little 15min show called 'The Boffin, The Builder, The Bombardier' that was no doubt made up to fill up the remainder of the hour left by the 45minutes of Doctor Who.
This is a curious little show of which AWB has managed to watch three episodes. The format seems obviously inspired by that of Mythbusters but while Adam and Jamie play themselves on that programme, the title three in this Australian grown production seem to be characters. Are they actually who they claim? Stuff if AWB knows and the ABC website is annoyingly vague.
What we get is a friendly little 15 minutes where they put forward some item from military history, dress up a bit in some mock period clothing, and then see if it will work, all with added explosives.
So far in the three episodes observed we have seen the ANZAC periscope rifle, a Chinese multi tube firelance launcher and the water drip rifle used during the evacuation of the Gallipoli campaign. Slight Australian theme as one would expect from an Australian production but AWB is unsure from the rapid reading of the credits just how much support, if any, the programme is getting from places like the Australian War Memorial.
So what are they like?
Well, average to silly. The periscope rifle was probably the best of what AWB has seen so far. They put forward the premise that reports into the weapons effective range seem to vary greatly and so, having built one, set out to range test the weapon to see what results were obtained.
(Spoilers - effective out to 100m, incredibly difficult to aim beyond that and Bruce Willis' character was really dead all along.)
So useful historical information and light TV entertainment. Win.
The other two eps? Not so much.
The drip rifle never really seemed to prove anything or indeed even offer a point to prove in the first place. For those not up on ANZAC folk law, the drip rifle was used during the evacuation to give off random rifle shots in the vague direction of the Turkish lines while the final rearguard did a bunk. Water from one tin slowly dripped until the weight change toppled the carefully balanced box of rocks and pulled the string connected trigger. Bang.
Since this arrangement is known to have worked and can clearly be shown to have worked, the team were left with very little to actually prove. They spent most of the first half of that ep musing on drip rates to gain the magic 32 minutes, without really giving any solid evidence as to why 32 minutes was a magic number. Yes the final rearguard was given 32 minutes (or there abouts, AWB is writing from memory here) to reach the final boats but that does not necessarily automatically translate into a solid need to have the timer work exactly at that time. Indeed if all drip rifles were 'set' to the same time, a sudden ragged volley from up and down the ANZAC line would probably prove more suspicious to the watching Turks then no fire at all.
Then, having proved the timer works, the team gave the final conclusion, without really offering up more then personal opinion, that the drip rifle probably didn't do all that much anyway and it was the other careful deception ploys that had the most effect.
Sure, so, ummm, what have we actually been proving again?
Last ep viewed by AWB was about Chinese multiple fire lance launchers. Think a big box with multiple gunpowder rocker powered spears that no doubt has a much more impressive name that AWB is too lazy to research.
So, our trio of harmless eccentrics, having read (Western) reports that dismissed the weapon, decided to prove it could work. A Noble enough challenge, but very casually executed.
First they build their launcher out of PVC pipe and other modern tools, which is a bit like proving that da Vinci could have flown by visiting Boeing, and then fire said rockets and launcher at a small horde of what one assumes were MDF man sized targets cunningly disguised as Mongals. At no time is any indication or attempt at historical methods and seems at best to have been a logical guess. The weapon was then fired off where the spear tipped rockets flew off in the general direction of the targets (about 50m away, the range was never stated) and largely bounced off the MDF.
Okay, it was not a hugely historically accurate replica, the spear points seemed to be flame cut bits of mild sheet and well, who are we fooling, it was just three guys playing with fireworks.
The conclusion however? Oh this would be a deadly effective weapon.
Well, maybe if you had set out some hard ground rules like maximum range, reload vs closing speed of the enemy and didn't have the sidekick character actually carrying one of the spear points that had literally curled back on itself after bouncing off one of the targets we might, just maybe, take your conclusions a bit more seriously.
Conclusions? Historical bollocks but harmless and good natured fun.
ABC tv - Sundays, after Doctor Who.