With Dr Who FINALLY redeeming itself for the year after a string of frankly pretty bland offerings, AWB sits down again on a Sunday night to watch more liberties being taken with history in the name of light entertainment.
This ep of The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier, which is apparently ep6 for those trying to follow the semi random screening order they seem to be shown in, has proved a slightly tricky one for AWB to review. On the plus side, the show finally shows some wargame figures, thereby completely vindicating AWB's decision to follow this little show for the last 8 weeks. A table full of 25s are used about mid point through the screening to give the new viewers a bit of an idea of what was actually happening in the battle they were describing, although points must be deducted as AWB is a firm believer that wargaming figures look silly with a gloss varnish.
More points are lost because the ep basically revolves around an obscure little period of European history at the start of the 19th Century that frankly is poorly documented, not very popular and of little interest to anyone. Napoleon? Never heard of him.
Okay, AWB concedes that some people MAY have heard of Napoleon, but would rather study tanks. That is the AWB mission statement and AWB will be sticking to it.
So, frantically googling to brush up on the background details, we push on with the review.
Basically our gang have got themselves a 3pdr of some sort to play with and are going to use the 1807 Battle of Friedland as an excuse to shoot it. Friedland, to paraphrase, was a battle between Russia and France that the French won and forced the Treaties of Tilsit and ended the War of the Fourth Coalition. The premise for the show was that Senarmont, then a corps artillery commander, established the principles of modern artillery by concentrating fire on a single target.
Now, as confessed before, AWB is not a shining depository of Napoleonic knowledge but some of the assumptions made here do seem very generalised and mildly misleading. A better informed description of what Senarmont did during this battle can probably be found HERE and since anything AWB is about to say was discovered from that website anyway, let us just give credit where due and direct people to the link.
What does seem to have been skipped over is the stage of the battle at which Senarmont did his party trick. The battle involved the Russians crossing over the river in order to try and smash an isolated French force and ending up being dragged into a major battle as the rest of the French army arrived. Towards evening the Russians were forced back into a constricted space with their backs to the river and it was then when Senarmont advanced his batteries and fired into the massed targets. Of minor detail not mentioned on TBCubed was the fact that Senarmont didn't do this alone, but had a battalion of infantry and four regiments of dragoons to cover him and from the accounts read by AWB, the Russians were unable or unwilling to actively counter the move forward. This sort of implies to AWB that the true conclusion to be made is not that massed firepower is a great idea (which AWB doesn't necessarily disagree with) but that aggressive use of artillery was possible or perhaps more importantly, aggressive use of a combined arms battle group was a very good and effective idea.
TBCubed rounded off the ep by showing in simple terms what happens if you break and attempt to run in the face of cavalry by having Will (the buttmonkey character) be chased across the paddock by a suitably dressed horsewoman with a big sword. (Spoiler - if you run, you die...). What did grate a bit for AWB was the casual way mounted troops were described as 'opportunists' of the battlefield and thereby reducing the reputation of an entire arm into some sort of casuals who rather then being able to dictate decisions on the battlefield, merely reacted to them.
Also rising a brief eyebrow was the attempt to explain the concept of Fog of War, a situation not actually done badly at all by our Boffin presenter, but by the war the phrase actually seems to have come full circle. Credited by most (or at least by AWB) to be a term invented by von Clausewitz to describe the literal fog produced on the battlefield by massed blackpowder weapons that reduced visibility and increased confusion, the term is so well understood by the current generation of computer/console gamers to mean limited intelligence that our Boffin had to explain that the fog of war was in this period literal in a strange case of the origin of the word coming full circle. Well, AWB was amused by it at least...
So, how much do we enjoy this episode?
Big points for showing how a muzzle loaded smooth bore cannon was operated and what a canister blast was like, points for showing the dangers of trying to run in the face of mounted troops and double plus points for the wargaming figures, but again, minus points for the massive generalisations that keep getting made that seem, to AWB at least, like they could have easily been tightened up without losing the attention of the intended audience.
Oh and massive points loss for the ABC for still not having a remotely useful supporting website.
Welcome to Another Wargaming Blog, where your hosts will update randomly and infequencently about whatever takes their gaming fancy.
Spelling Optional.
Spelling Optional.
Showing posts with label Artillery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Artillery. Show all posts
Sunday, 19 May 2013
Monday, 13 May 2013
TV - Boffins under Siege - The Trebuchet
Another Sunday and another night of light entertainment on TV as AWB current favourite free to air programming came and went. All good fun, unlike that rubbish Neil Gaiman wrote via twitter just before.
Curiously the ABC lists this ep as number 7 and last weeks (the Spencer Rifle) is listed as 8. No real idea what happened to number 6. Minor problems I am sure but if you are trying to follow at home good luck to you.
This week (or last weeks depending on numbering system) our three heroes from The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier go all medieval on us and discuss the premier pre gunpowder siege weapon, the Trebuchet. The good news here is that like last week (or next week if you prefer) the trio don't try too hard by making bold statements they can't actually prove. The framework of the programme was that the Trebuchet evolved during the so called 'Dark Ages' and the so called much more clever Romans never used them. So, ignoring the slip that the 'Dark Ages' were actually before the 'Medieval' period where the Trebuchet was actually used, the question was raised as to was this actually an effective and well designed weapon or just a hack job a mere shadow of what the Romans could have built.
Having clearly blown their budget on all those 303 rifles, the team fail to build us a full scale behemoth and instead drag out what seems to be a commercial of the shelf working model about one metre high. Jokes aside that is fair enough, they clearly do have a budget to work within but one does have to wonder why they have 'The Builder' on the programme when he often doesn't actually seem to build anything. More on the 'characters' later.
They then fling some oranges and a toy cow at a small cardboard castle before blowing it up. As you do.
Conclusions, it was a very effective weapon that could do exactly what was said on the box.
Problems really are with the casual history. No weapon exists in a vacuum, and one of the reasons why there was an evolutionary break in the development of siege weapons from Roman to Medieval times was that for a great hunk of history people stopped building decent fortifications. It is often forgotten that it was the Normans that brought castles to the British Isles and those were the much smaller Motte and Bailey style and even then, most of the first ones were made of wood. Catapults in the Roman sense were largely forgotten because most defencive works could be more easily taken using a bunch of big hairy men with some homemade ladders. The other point of interest with the historical period was that there was no real 'Engineering Class' of skilled siege specialists passing down their skills from master to apprentice. Siege, while common, was more often a case of camping outside and hoping they surrendered before your own troops got bored and attempting to knock down the walls was actually relatively uncommon. The skills to make siege equipment it seems were no so much magically unlocked like a computer game tech tree, as rediscovered and forgotten time and time again over hundreds of years and it is most likely that the people knocking down the walls with siege engines were the same skilled master craftsman who had used their knowledge of levers, pulleys and woodwork to build the great walls in the first place.
Still, a lot of history to compress into 10 minutes so let us start to muse on the shows format instead.
This ep re-introduced the character of 'Big Mama', a woman 'in her prime' who has been used before to explain to these three overgrown boys the hard physics of their problems. One guesses that this character was introduced to play up on the 'men and sheds' social stereotype where no matter how many tools a man has, he is still just a big boy trying to impress his mates and only a woman really knows how to talk sense.
Which might actually be fine if this character actually got to talk some sense.
We are given a brief 'physics' lesson on how the Big T actually works by said Big Mama, and unfortunately most of what she says is crock. A Trebuchet is effectively a long arm rotating around a pivot. Now rotational velocity is the same at both ends and, if AWB remembers correctly from Uni days, is measured in radians per second. However, the further you move away from the centre of rotation, the faster the tangential velocity and in practical terms for us in this situation, the faster our big rock is flung. Of course the Trebuchet is also a balance lever. To get one end to go down, allowing for the mechanical advantage of the lever arm, it must be heavier then the other. So Trebuchet design is in reality a compromise between size of the counter balance, length of the arms, how far they are actually hoping to throw and how big they are prepared to build the thing in the first place. Having some mother figure sprout out some dross about ratios doesn't make it otherwise and is a small step away from technobabble.
This brings us back to actual dynamic of our trio within the show. Unlike say 'Mythbusters' where the hosts are effectively being themselves and just goofing it up, TBCubed are playing classic cliched roles. Why they have chosen to do this is open to ponder. A careful pausing of the credits has finally confirmed to AWB that the head writer is also the man playing 'The Boffin' and hence is must be assumed that he (John Concannon) does actually know a respectable amount of his history. However, instead of playing himself in a sort of Adam and Jamie Mythbusters dynamic, he instead takes the role of the bully. Tony, 'The Bombardier' is the thug enforcer character and Will 'The Builder' (who as we have pointed out earlier, often doesn't build anything) gets the role of the butt monkey the crueler pair keep around as their play thing. If 'Big Mama' is seen as the school teacher bringing the schoolboys back in line then the entire show develops a disturbing parallel to the worse of most people's schooling years.
Hmmm... Still an entertaining 10 minutes of TV that AWB has been enjoying the viewing of, and all attempts at making TV of military history must really be supported, but it does have the fault of being just a tad silly.
Curiously the ABC lists this ep as number 7 and last weeks (the Spencer Rifle) is listed as 8. No real idea what happened to number 6. Minor problems I am sure but if you are trying to follow at home good luck to you.
This week (or last weeks depending on numbering system) our three heroes from The Boffin The Builder and The Bombardier go all medieval on us and discuss the premier pre gunpowder siege weapon, the Trebuchet. The good news here is that like last week (or next week if you prefer) the trio don't try too hard by making bold statements they can't actually prove. The framework of the programme was that the Trebuchet evolved during the so called 'Dark Ages' and the so called much more clever Romans never used them. So, ignoring the slip that the 'Dark Ages' were actually before the 'Medieval' period where the Trebuchet was actually used, the question was raised as to was this actually an effective and well designed weapon or just a hack job a mere shadow of what the Romans could have built.
Having clearly blown their budget on all those 303 rifles, the team fail to build us a full scale behemoth and instead drag out what seems to be a commercial of the shelf working model about one metre high. Jokes aside that is fair enough, they clearly do have a budget to work within but one does have to wonder why they have 'The Builder' on the programme when he often doesn't actually seem to build anything. More on the 'characters' later.
They then fling some oranges and a toy cow at a small cardboard castle before blowing it up. As you do.
Conclusions, it was a very effective weapon that could do exactly what was said on the box.
Problems really are with the casual history. No weapon exists in a vacuum, and one of the reasons why there was an evolutionary break in the development of siege weapons from Roman to Medieval times was that for a great hunk of history people stopped building decent fortifications. It is often forgotten that it was the Normans that brought castles to the British Isles and those were the much smaller Motte and Bailey style and even then, most of the first ones were made of wood. Catapults in the Roman sense were largely forgotten because most defencive works could be more easily taken using a bunch of big hairy men with some homemade ladders. The other point of interest with the historical period was that there was no real 'Engineering Class' of skilled siege specialists passing down their skills from master to apprentice. Siege, while common, was more often a case of camping outside and hoping they surrendered before your own troops got bored and attempting to knock down the walls was actually relatively uncommon. The skills to make siege equipment it seems were no so much magically unlocked like a computer game tech tree, as rediscovered and forgotten time and time again over hundreds of years and it is most likely that the people knocking down the walls with siege engines were the same skilled master craftsman who had used their knowledge of levers, pulleys and woodwork to build the great walls in the first place.
Still, a lot of history to compress into 10 minutes so let us start to muse on the shows format instead.
This ep re-introduced the character of 'Big Mama', a woman 'in her prime' who has been used before to explain to these three overgrown boys the hard physics of their problems. One guesses that this character was introduced to play up on the 'men and sheds' social stereotype where no matter how many tools a man has, he is still just a big boy trying to impress his mates and only a woman really knows how to talk sense.
Which might actually be fine if this character actually got to talk some sense.
We are given a brief 'physics' lesson on how the Big T actually works by said Big Mama, and unfortunately most of what she says is crock. A Trebuchet is effectively a long arm rotating around a pivot. Now rotational velocity is the same at both ends and, if AWB remembers correctly from Uni days, is measured in radians per second. However, the further you move away from the centre of rotation, the faster the tangential velocity and in practical terms for us in this situation, the faster our big rock is flung. Of course the Trebuchet is also a balance lever. To get one end to go down, allowing for the mechanical advantage of the lever arm, it must be heavier then the other. So Trebuchet design is in reality a compromise between size of the counter balance, length of the arms, how far they are actually hoping to throw and how big they are prepared to build the thing in the first place. Having some mother figure sprout out some dross about ratios doesn't make it otherwise and is a small step away from technobabble.
This brings us back to actual dynamic of our trio within the show. Unlike say 'Mythbusters' where the hosts are effectively being themselves and just goofing it up, TBCubed are playing classic cliched roles. Why they have chosen to do this is open to ponder. A careful pausing of the credits has finally confirmed to AWB that the head writer is also the man playing 'The Boffin' and hence is must be assumed that he (John Concannon) does actually know a respectable amount of his history. However, instead of playing himself in a sort of Adam and Jamie Mythbusters dynamic, he instead takes the role of the bully. Tony, 'The Bombardier' is the thug enforcer character and Will 'The Builder' (who as we have pointed out earlier, often doesn't build anything) gets the role of the butt monkey the crueler pair keep around as their play thing. If 'Big Mama' is seen as the school teacher bringing the schoolboys back in line then the entire show develops a disturbing parallel to the worse of most people's schooling years.
Hmmm... Still an entertaining 10 minutes of TV that AWB has been enjoying the viewing of, and all attempts at making TV of military history must really be supported, but it does have the fault of being just a tad silly.
Wednesday, 1 May 2013
Musing on Artillery
AWB has been doing some casual research into the multi model joy that is WW1 era artillery, and, as a result, has been musing on just what a significant development the French 75 actually was. The Matériel de 75mm Mle 1897, to give the weapon it's official name, can probably safely be called the first of the 'Modern Artillery' systems to go into service anywhere in the world, yet it's significance is probably mostly ignored by most casual students of history.
The evolution of tube artillery broadly went something like this;
- Muzzle loading smoothbore
- Muzzle loading rifled
- Breech loading
- 'Modern' weapons with recoil systems.
The progression wasn't smooth of course. Breech loading cannons of various forms date back to the beginning of gunpowder. Smoothbore cannons had some advantages over rifled cannons so both existed on the 19th Century battlefield for many years and even when breech loading had finally come up for consideration again, it was years before it managed to replace muzzle loading with some nations. The Royal Navy, having embraced the Armstrong breech loader in about 1860, decided the technology could go with a bit longer in the oven and went back to muzzle loading rifles. They stuck with such weapons probably a little longer then they needed to, eventually peaking with the RML 16 inch 80 ton weapons fitted to HMS Inflexible.
(Armstrong made an even bigger 17.7inch 100 ton weapon but even the RN decided enough was enough at that stage. The weapons were sold to Italy for some of her battleships or used on coast defence batteries in Malta and Gibraltar.)
The 75 however was a massive leap in weaponry. The key feature was of course the recoil system, a hydro-pneumatic system so advanced that it had taken designers nearly 15 years to get the idea to work successfully. This smooth and reliable system allowed the other advanced features of the gun; the automatic fuse setter and a rapid to operate breech system, to be used to their full effect. The gun could literally be fired at a rate of 30 shots per minute, a speed that was the physical upper limit based on the 2 second cycle time of the recoil system.
What is more, since unlike other guns of that period, the gun would not need to be significantly re-aimed after each shot and each of those 30 shots could be expected to go pretty much where they were intended.
Was this significant?
You better believe it.
Terence Zuber in his (cough) 'interesting' book* 'The Real Schlieffen Plan' goes as far as to claim that the German discovery of this weapon when they saw it in action during the Boxer Rebellion was enough to make them tear up their current strategic war plans and start again. Other nations, well aware of the massive rate of fire advantage this weapon had, rapidly developed or purchased their own equivalent weapons and, perhaps most significantly, the French effectively redesigned their entire battlefield tactics around it.
As we mentioned, the 75 had a very high rate of fire and a battery firing shrapnel shells was well equipped to place large areas of open ground under deadly barrages. A 1914 French Infantry division had no other artillery then this weapon and indeed a French Corps, unlike other nations which might be expected to have heavy field or howitzers, had more batteries of this gun.
However, while it was definitely a major milestone in artillery, it has also been argued that the French love affair with this weapon may have been a little unwise. Paul Strong and Sanders Marble in 'Artillery in the Great War' make the observation that in the opening battles of WW1 the superior French field artillery made a mess of the German infantry, right up to the time when the superior German HEAVY artillery suppressed and silenced the batteries.The go on to claim that a prime reason of the Allied success in the Battle of Marne was that the over extended Germans had finally advanced faster then their heavy artillery could follow and the French 75s were finally allowed to do what they were intended unopposed.
However, digressing as per usual, the point AWB really wants to muse over is how do we show these sort of technical advances on the wargames table. By the time we get to WW1 most armies, at least for their first line divisions, had quick firing field weapons. However, due to the rapid need to expand and find heavy artillery, a lot of obsolete guns were brought back into service or dragged out of distant fortresses for use on the front. The Germans were possibly an exception to this rule, but the British for example sent many 5inch Howitzers to France and used them all through 1915. These older weapons lacked recoil systems and had a practical max rate of fire of 2 shots per minute - slightly slower then the 15 or so shots most more modern guns can get off.
This brings us back to our gaming. How do our favourite rules show it, or more importantly, do we need to show it at all?
If we are modelling the slow grind of a bombardment, then probably not. While modern guns could fire faster, most work was conducted at a more sedate 1 or 2 shots per minute. There is also the very real consideration of the 'Shell Shortage' and the fact that many batteries simply didn't have enough shells to do rapid firing even if they needed to.
The really simple solution is to just ignore it totally and abstract indirect fire into an abstract where who or what fires it is not of importance. The slightly more detailed is to rationalise that shells fired x shell size = damage factor and roll against that. A simple enough concept but ignores the fact that the difference between a relatively small 'field' gun shell of say 5-6kg and the 23kg of the 5inch BL we mentioned earlier.
A field gun in many cases often completely lacked the ability to destroy entrenchments, where a heavy shell was going to collapse trenchwalls and smash firing positions. This was significant and part of the reason armies were willing to field and maintain so many different artillery types. Some guns were just better at some roles.
Each wargame system and indeed each wargamer has their own views on what makes a fun night pushing lead or counters, and each has their own view on what is worth including in a rule system. The point that AWB is trying to make is that a bigger gun/howitzer isn't just a stand with more firepower, it is a stand with DIFFERENT firepower. Field artillery can, will and did butcher troops in the open. It also can't, wont and didn't damage troops dug in. So, while your personally gaming experience is always your own, AWB would like to see games that note the difference between field and heavy shelling.
Of course AWB would also like to see game with a few less rubbish dice rolls so maybe we can't have everything...
* Interesting? Is AWB implying that they didn't really like 'The Real Schlieffen Plan'? Short answer? Yes. Zuber is an American who was posted for many years in Germany as part of his US Army service and does appear to have gone, as we say, 'native'**. While AWB has no doubt that Zuber has done a lot of research, reading his text did give the impression his book was one edit away from using the phrase 'gentle peaceloving Germans'. Zuber seems to have gone to great length to point out that Germany was forced into a defencive war against the overly aggressive Allied powers that tends to distract from his overall argument. The argument itself, namely that there was NOT actually a Schlieffen plan ends up becoming a bit moot. We all know and accept that Germany marched through Belgium so arguing if the plan existed or not unfortunately ends up a bit like claiming in your murder trial that you didn't stab the victim to death, you slashed his throat instead.
** Not that there is anything wrong with going native. AWB are big fans of Germany *** and German culture and happily pay credit to the success over the centuries of these people in both peace and war.
*** Except Hamburg
The evolution of tube artillery broadly went something like this;
- Muzzle loading smoothbore
- Muzzle loading rifled
- Breech loading
- 'Modern' weapons with recoil systems.
The progression wasn't smooth of course. Breech loading cannons of various forms date back to the beginning of gunpowder. Smoothbore cannons had some advantages over rifled cannons so both existed on the 19th Century battlefield for many years and even when breech loading had finally come up for consideration again, it was years before it managed to replace muzzle loading with some nations. The Royal Navy, having embraced the Armstrong breech loader in about 1860, decided the technology could go with a bit longer in the oven and went back to muzzle loading rifles. They stuck with such weapons probably a little longer then they needed to, eventually peaking with the RML 16 inch 80 ton weapons fitted to HMS Inflexible.
(Armstrong made an even bigger 17.7inch 100 ton weapon but even the RN decided enough was enough at that stage. The weapons were sold to Italy for some of her battleships or used on coast defence batteries in Malta and Gibraltar.)
The 75 however was a massive leap in weaponry. The key feature was of course the recoil system, a hydro-pneumatic system so advanced that it had taken designers nearly 15 years to get the idea to work successfully. This smooth and reliable system allowed the other advanced features of the gun; the automatic fuse setter and a rapid to operate breech system, to be used to their full effect. The gun could literally be fired at a rate of 30 shots per minute, a speed that was the physical upper limit based on the 2 second cycle time of the recoil system.
What is more, since unlike other guns of that period, the gun would not need to be significantly re-aimed after each shot and each of those 30 shots could be expected to go pretty much where they were intended.
Was this significant?
You better believe it.
Terence Zuber in his (cough) 'interesting' book* 'The Real Schlieffen Plan' goes as far as to claim that the German discovery of this weapon when they saw it in action during the Boxer Rebellion was enough to make them tear up their current strategic war plans and start again. Other nations, well aware of the massive rate of fire advantage this weapon had, rapidly developed or purchased their own equivalent weapons and, perhaps most significantly, the French effectively redesigned their entire battlefield tactics around it.
As we mentioned, the 75 had a very high rate of fire and a battery firing shrapnel shells was well equipped to place large areas of open ground under deadly barrages. A 1914 French Infantry division had no other artillery then this weapon and indeed a French Corps, unlike other nations which might be expected to have heavy field or howitzers, had more batteries of this gun.
However, while it was definitely a major milestone in artillery, it has also been argued that the French love affair with this weapon may have been a little unwise. Paul Strong and Sanders Marble in 'Artillery in the Great War' make the observation that in the opening battles of WW1 the superior French field artillery made a mess of the German infantry, right up to the time when the superior German HEAVY artillery suppressed and silenced the batteries.The go on to claim that a prime reason of the Allied success in the Battle of Marne was that the over extended Germans had finally advanced faster then their heavy artillery could follow and the French 75s were finally allowed to do what they were intended unopposed.
However, digressing as per usual, the point AWB really wants to muse over is how do we show these sort of technical advances on the wargames table. By the time we get to WW1 most armies, at least for their first line divisions, had quick firing field weapons. However, due to the rapid need to expand and find heavy artillery, a lot of obsolete guns were brought back into service or dragged out of distant fortresses for use on the front. The Germans were possibly an exception to this rule, but the British for example sent many 5inch Howitzers to France and used them all through 1915. These older weapons lacked recoil systems and had a practical max rate of fire of 2 shots per minute - slightly slower then the 15 or so shots most more modern guns can get off.
This brings us back to our gaming. How do our favourite rules show it, or more importantly, do we need to show it at all?
If we are modelling the slow grind of a bombardment, then probably not. While modern guns could fire faster, most work was conducted at a more sedate 1 or 2 shots per minute. There is also the very real consideration of the 'Shell Shortage' and the fact that many batteries simply didn't have enough shells to do rapid firing even if they needed to.
The really simple solution is to just ignore it totally and abstract indirect fire into an abstract where who or what fires it is not of importance. The slightly more detailed is to rationalise that shells fired x shell size = damage factor and roll against that. A simple enough concept but ignores the fact that the difference between a relatively small 'field' gun shell of say 5-6kg and the 23kg of the 5inch BL we mentioned earlier.
A field gun in many cases often completely lacked the ability to destroy entrenchments, where a heavy shell was going to collapse trenchwalls and smash firing positions. This was significant and part of the reason armies were willing to field and maintain so many different artillery types. Some guns were just better at some roles.
Each wargame system and indeed each wargamer has their own views on what makes a fun night pushing lead or counters, and each has their own view on what is worth including in a rule system. The point that AWB is trying to make is that a bigger gun/howitzer isn't just a stand with more firepower, it is a stand with DIFFERENT firepower. Field artillery can, will and did butcher troops in the open. It also can't, wont and didn't damage troops dug in. So, while your personally gaming experience is always your own, AWB would like to see games that note the difference between field and heavy shelling.
Of course AWB would also like to see game with a few less rubbish dice rolls so maybe we can't have everything...
* Interesting? Is AWB implying that they didn't really like 'The Real Schlieffen Plan'? Short answer? Yes. Zuber is an American who was posted for many years in Germany as part of his US Army service and does appear to have gone, as we say, 'native'**. While AWB has no doubt that Zuber has done a lot of research, reading his text did give the impression his book was one edit away from using the phrase 'gentle peaceloving Germans'. Zuber seems to have gone to great length to point out that Germany was forced into a defencive war against the overly aggressive Allied powers that tends to distract from his overall argument. The argument itself, namely that there was NOT actually a Schlieffen plan ends up becoming a bit moot. We all know and accept that Germany marched through Belgium so arguing if the plan existed or not unfortunately ends up a bit like claiming in your murder trial that you didn't stab the victim to death, you slashed his throat instead.
** Not that there is anything wrong with going native. AWB are big fans of Germany *** and German culture and happily pay credit to the success over the centuries of these people in both peace and war.
*** Except Hamburg
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)